
- Home
- First Day of School
- Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Make The Grade Pencils - 12 pencils.
Description
Specifications
Description
Specifications
Reviews
Review Snapshot
by PowerReviews
Ratings Distribution
5 Stars
26
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Most Liked Positive Review
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it wh...ich means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
Most Liked Critical Review
Disappointing Quality
These pencils are so cute and I have used them for many years as a first day surprise. However, they don't make the grade and I will not be spending my money on them next year. Many of the pencils broke as soon as they were sharpened or they did not sharpen to a point because the lead is not cen...tered correctly. I have thrown away about a third of what I purchased.
Reviewed by 33 customers
Not worth it
I like the looks of these pencils, but they will not sharpen in the electric or manual pencil sharpener. They show a sharp point, but it snaps off or falls out right away. Frustrating and not the quality I am used to from this company.

Official Response by Really Good Stuff
We apologize for the inconvenience and we are sad to hear that you do not like the item.. For replacements of missing or damaged items/parts - Please contact our Customer Service department toll free at 877-867-1920, Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM (EST) for further assistance.
Great pencils!
I love these pencils. They sharpen right away and keep their point. Many pencils today keep breaking off and you end of with half a pencil in a short period of time.
I buy them again and again!
These go in my welcome pencil boxes year after year. It isn't easy to find pencils that are specific to fifth grade so these have become my go-to year after year! They sharpen well, so if your nervous that they will not sharpen well or are cheap, don't be. These are high quality and very cute!
I would buy this product again
Student love getting a personalized ANYTHING on the first day of school.
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it which means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Customizable
- Durable
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Good Organization
- Good Value
- Unique
- Versatile
- Best for
- Classroom
- Group Use
- Organization
- Single Student Use
Nice way to start the year
nice BOY gift bag goodie
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Young Children
Nice
Really good for first day of school or open house as a "welcome" gift. Looking forward to giving them to my 3rd graders.
- Pros
- Attractive
- Fun
- Best for
- Everyday Use
Undisclosed
Cute gift for students!
- Pros
- Fun
- Good Value
- Best for
- Group Use
Great
Great welcome pencils
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Everyday Use
- Single Student Use


Review Snapshot
by PowerReviews
Ratings Distribution
5 Stars
26
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Most Liked Positive Review
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it wh...ich means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
Most Liked Critical Review
Disappointing Quality
These pencils are so cute and I have used them for many years as a first day surprise. However, they don't make the grade and I will not be spending my money on them next year. Many of the pencils broke as soon as they were sharpened or they did not sharpen to a point because the lead is not cen...tered correctly. I have thrown away about a third of what I purchased.
Reviewed by 33 customers
Not worth it
I like the looks of these pencils, but they will not sharpen in the electric or manual pencil sharpener. They show a sharp point, but it snaps off or falls out right away. Frustrating and not the quality I am used to from this company.

Official Response by Really Good Stuff
We apologize for the inconvenience and we are sad to hear that you do not like the item.. For replacements of missing or damaged items/parts - Please contact our Customer Service department toll free at 877-867-1920, Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM (EST) for further assistance.
Great pencils!
I love these pencils. They sharpen right away and keep their point. Many pencils today keep breaking off and you end of with half a pencil in a short period of time.
I buy them again and again!
These go in my welcome pencil boxes year after year. It isn't easy to find pencils that are specific to fifth grade so these have become my go-to year after year! They sharpen well, so if your nervous that they will not sharpen well or are cheap, don't be. These are high quality and very cute!
I would buy this product again
Student love getting a personalized ANYTHING on the first day of school.
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it which means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Customizable
- Durable
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Good Organization
- Good Value
- Unique
- Versatile
- Best for
- Classroom
- Group Use
- Organization
- Single Student Use
Nice way to start the year
nice BOY gift bag goodie
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Young Children
Nice
Really good for first day of school or open house as a "welcome" gift. Looking forward to giving them to my 3rd graders.
- Pros
- Attractive
- Fun
- Best for
- Everyday Use
Undisclosed
Cute gift for students!
- Pros
- Fun
- Good Value
- Best for
- Group Use
Great
Great welcome pencils
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Everyday Use
- Single Student Use
Review Snapshot
by PowerReviews
Ratings Distribution
5 Stars
26
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
Pros
Cons
Best Uses
Most Liked Positive Review
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it wh...ich means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
Most Liked Critical Review
Disappointing Quality
These pencils are so cute and I have used them for many years as a first day surprise. However, they don't make the grade and I will not be spending my money on them next year. Many of the pencils broke as soon as they were sharpened or they did not sharpen to a point because the lead is not cen...tered correctly. I have thrown away about a third of what I purchased.
Reviewed by 33 customers
Not worth it
I like the looks of these pencils, but they will not sharpen in the electric or manual pencil sharpener. They show a sharp point, but it snaps off or falls out right away. Frustrating and not the quality I am used to from this company.

Official Response by Really Good Stuff
We apologize for the inconvenience and we are sad to hear that you do not like the item.. For replacements of missing or damaged items/parts - Please contact our Customer Service department toll free at 877-867-1920, Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM (EST) for further assistance.
Great pencils!
I love these pencils. They sharpen right away and keep their point. Many pencils today keep breaking off and you end of with half a pencil in a short period of time.
I buy them again and again!
These go in my welcome pencil boxes year after year. It isn't easy to find pencils that are specific to fifth grade so these have become my go-to year after year! They sharpen well, so if your nervous that they will not sharpen well or are cheap, don't be. These are high quality and very cute!
I would buy this product again
Student love getting a personalized ANYTHING on the first day of school.
Great Pencil
I bought these pencils to put in my Kindergartners homework boxes this year! I also put a couple of them in the pencil cup by our Sign In sheet. the students feel extra special when they get to use the pencils. Many of them asked me to inform their siblings that the pencil have Kindergarten on it which means that they are the only ones that could use it!As far as using them in the class, I think that its a great way to be possessive when other teachers/students ask to borrow pencils. They will always know where to return it!
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Customizable
- Durable
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Good Organization
- Good Value
- Unique
- Versatile
- Best for
- Classroom
- Group Use
- Organization
- Single Student Use
Nice way to start the year
nice BOY gift bag goodie
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Young Children
Nice
Really good for first day of school or open house as a "welcome" gift. Looking forward to giving them to my 3rd graders.
- Pros
- Attractive
- Fun
- Best for
- Everyday Use
Undisclosed
Cute gift for students!
- Pros
- Fun
- Good Value
- Best for
- Group Use
Great
Great welcome pencils
- Pros
- Attractive
- Colorful
- Easy To Use
- Fun
- Best for
- Classroom
- Everyday Use
- Single Student Use